I've been reading Bird by Bird, Some Instructions on Writing and Life by Anne Lamott. The first two big pieces of advice she gives are things I already knew, but it’s like “Writing for Dummies”, explaining things on a level that motivates rather than confuses.
The two pieces of advice are this. First, look at the small picture. Second, write badly and then edit. What follows here is stage one (bad writing) and stage two (rough draft of a poem) of a writing project based on that advice.
The author did her own project with school lunches and it made me think about school lunches, and it was the first time I’d felt like writing about anything in a while, so I figured I’d steal the idea. So here goes.
STAGE I: Everything I can think about about school lunches.
I hated peanut butter as a kid. And warm baloney with ketchup soaked into pasty white bread. I didn't like processed American cheese. Yeah, I was a picky eater. My mother didn't let us kids get away with much, but for some reason, I got away with that. She made me special lunches. I had egg salad every day, with lettuce on both sides so that the mayonnaise wouldn't soak through to the bread. I'm sure it stunk up my locker, but I don't remember that, I only remember that I enjoyed my lunch. I did eventually learn to like peanut butter when I lived alone with no money for any other food, but to this day, egg salad is a comfort food, one I'm going to have for lunch today for that matter.
Then we come to the actual lunch room. I don't remember a lot about the one at my high school. I remember it being loud. I remember that I had a set of friends to sit with so whatever happened in the rest of the cafeteria didn't really matter. But I also remember wishing I could buy my lunch, or really, a big cookie. The lunches didn’t look so hot. The cookies did.
The lunch line was full of people I really didn't want to associate with. This was 1968-1971, when it was cool to not be cool. The people in the lunch line were jocks and socs (social girls), and us hippies didn't want anything to do with them. Their lunch time ran in the opposite direction of ours. We would pay out nickel to the milk machine, eat our brown bag lunches, then hang out. They hung out in the lunch line, then had to quickly eat their food at the end of the period. But man, I wanted one of those cookies.
Now I’m a teacher, so I have to deal with lunchrooms again. My first year at the high school where I teach, I had cafeteria duty. What I noticed first was that I was impressed with the racial integration. That didn't happen at my high school. At this one however, there were some groups that were all white, or all black, but there were at least as many groups that were integrated. Some of them were obvious "groups", like the members of the anime club. And those who sat and did their homework, sharing math books and problems over their lunches.
I also noticed the food. For all that we try to be a "no junk" cafeteria, kids still find ways to get around that. I've seen kids with two orders of french fries for their lunch.
Now it seems I've come full circle. I don't have lunch duty anymore, and I avoid the lunchroom. Instead I brown bag it, have lunch in the library where I can have peace and quiet, and don't have to deal with the kids in the lunch line. They’re still obnoxious
STAGE II: Rough draft of a poem.
Here’s the draft of the poem. I actually think I can get a second, children’s, poem out of this but I’m just thrilled I got past my not writing. I need to keep reading Bird by Bird.
I bring my brown bag lunch to school -
egg salad, oreo cookies.
The kids in the crowded lunch line
shout, laugh, punch each others' arms.
Egg salad, oreo cookies,
same thing every day. I watch boys
shout, laugh, punch each others' arms,
don't envy the mystery meat.
Same thing every day. I watch boys
with my friends. They brown bag it too,
don't envy the mystery meat,
wish for five-cent fresh-baked cookies.
With my friends (they brown bag it too)
it doesn't matter we have no money,
wish for five-cent fresh-baked cookies.
We don’t waste time in the lunch line.
It doesn't matter we have no money.
Lunch is over much too quickly,
we don’t waste time in the lunch line,
enjoy the time instead of food.
Lunch is over much too quickly
now. A high school teacher, I still
enjoy the time instead of food,
want quiet away from students.
Now a high school teacher, I still
see noisy lunchrooms, haven’t changed,
want quiet away from students
clamoring for notice from peers.
See, noisy lunchrooms haven’t changed,
the kids in the crowded lunch line
clamoring for notice from peers.
I bring my brown bag lunch to school.


